Wanted: Beta Testers

With Simple Injector 3 we are breaking with the past and working hard to simplify the API to better represent our ideals and, of course, the name of our library. This means that we are introducing breaking changes in v3 that will undoubtedly impact any developer migrating from v2.

The driver for making these breaking changes is that areas of the API have evolved over time and in so doing have grown confusing (e.g. RegisterOpenGeneric and RegisterManyForOpenGeneric). In the pursuit of keeping Simple Injector simple we felt obligated to improve the consistency of the API. These decisions have not been taken lightly because we hate breaking your code. Our driving force is, however, a Simple(r) Injector for everyone.

We are doing our best to make the transition as seamless as possible and we need feedback on this effort. We are looking for Simple Injector users to test the beta of Simple Injector 3 and tell us what they think.

If you can help then please upgrade your NuGet packages to 3.0.0-beta1 3.0.0-beta2 3.0.0-beta3 3.0.0-beta4 and try to compile your code (it will probably fail!). Our main strategy is to guide users with obsolete messages that should be presented as descriptive compiler errors. Once you have fixed any errors please call Verify() on your container, (as you are hopefully already doing) and test your application to ensure everything resolves as expected. To discuss any element of beta testing please join us on gitter. We would usually expect the upgrade process to take no more than a half hour.

Please note that we don’t expect you to do our testing for us. Simple Injector has an extensive suite of unit tests and we don’t expect to have introduced many new bugs.

Here’s a list of the most prominent breaking changes we are introducing:

  • Calling Verify() will now automatically diagnose the container’s configuration for common configuration mistakes and exceptions will be thrown. We felt that not enough developers were explicitly calling Analyzer.Analyze() to check for diagnostic warnings, leading to a common source of bugs. So we decided to integrate this into Verification in the hope that this will guide our users to the pit of success. The old Verification behaviour can be triggered by calling Verify(VerificationOption.VerifyOnly).
  • Even if you don’t call Verify(), the v3 the container will always check for lifestyle mismatches when resolving an instance and will throw an exception if there is a mismatch in the object graph. This more strict behaviour can be suppressed globally but (for obvious reasons) we advise against doing so.
  • The RegisterSingle methods have been renamed to RegisterSingleton as we felt there was some ambiguity in the name RegisterSingle, especially in combination with methods like RegisterAll, RegisterCollection and RegisterManyForOpenGeneric. We considered removing these method completely, but the benefits of doing so did not compare favourably to the pain of fixing this as a breaking change.
  • The RegisterAll methods have been renamed to RegisterCollection. Just as with the RegisterSingle methods, new developers experienced confusion in their naming. The new name expresses more clearly what the methods do.
  • The RegisterManyForOpenGeneric extension methods from the SimpleInjector.Extensions namespace have been replaced with new Register and RegisterCollection overloads on the Container. When doing one-to-one mappings, Register(Type, IEnumerable<Assembly>) can be used, and when registering collections RegisterCollection(Type, IEnumerable<Assembly>) can be used.
  • The RegisterSingleDecorator extension methods have been removed. Decorators can be registered by calling RegisterDecorator while supplying the Lifestyle.Singleton.
  • The RegisterOpenGeneric extension methods have been removed. The Container.Register methods have been extended to accept open generic types. This removes the superficial difference between the registration of open generic types and other registrations. (This difference originally had a technical background, but we allowed the internal difference to effect the user experience.) Do note that there is a behavioural difference between RegisterOpenGeneric and Container.Register. RegisterOpenGeneric registers each generic type as fall-back, which means it will apply that type if no other registration exists for that type. Conversely, Container.Register will not register a fall-back, it will, instead, test for overlapping registrations. If the fall-back behaviour is required, the new RegisterConditional methods can be used. The new RegisterConditional methods allow supplying a delegate that allows signaling a registration as fall-back registration.
  • IConstructorVerificationBehavior and IConstructorVerificationBehavior have been merged and replaced with IDependencyInjectionBehavior.

In the majority of cases the compiler error messages should guide you through the migration. If you find a scenario that is unclear or it takes time to figure out please let us know. We want to make the migration as seamless as possible.

Besides the above list of breaking changes, we have some compelling new features that may be of interest:

  • A Lifestyle.Scoped property was added to simplify registration of scoped lifestyles, since in most applications you would typically only use one specific scoped lifestyle. You can now use Register<IService, Impl>(Lifestyle.Scoped) instead of having to call RegisterPerWebRequest<IService, Impl>() for example. This also simplifies reuse in your composition root, when the same configuration is reused over multiple application types (such as MVC and WCF).
  • As noted above RegisterConditional methods are added to the Container to allow registering types based on contextual information such as information about the consumer in which they are injected.
  • Batch registration made easier by adding overloads of the Register method that accept either a collection of types or a collection of assemblies.
  • As explained above, the Register methods now accept open generic types.
  • The container now implements IDisposable. This allows cached singletons to be disposed when the container gets disposed.
  • RegisterCollection(Type, IEnumerable<Registration>) now accepts open generic service types as well.

4 thoughts on “Wanted: Beta Testers

  1. I would be happy to test this on my project. I want to move my project to asp.net 5 at the most appropriate time, will simple injector v3 make that simple, have read somewhere that you don’t agree with some of the design choices so don’t fully integrate?

  2. Thanks Steven, my concern (possibly unfounded) with the link provided is that if I wanted to extend the pipeline myself and had a fully integrated cotainer I could use that one,but in the setup given I’d have to use both, I don’t know how feature rich (believe not very) or fast the me one is. This is all off topic though.. so in answer to the request, I will upgrade to v3 and let u know how I get on :-)

  3. Thanks for your job. I am using Simple Injector recently in my project , but i like it.

Comments are closed.